The author of the above article suggests that most of his unsaved friends use pronoun introductions. I had heard about it, but had not personally experienced it. Yesterday was the first time I had someone introduce themselves with pronouns. I was very confused because I thought she said she used he/her pronouns, but my wife later clarified that she had said she used she/her. I wanted to be polite to her, but was very confused and thankfully I was able to talk to her without using either. Perhaps I need to get a hearing aid so I do not end up offending someone. (I am not trying to be rude about the hearing aid thing, but as a child I was diagnosed with some hearing loss, so the distinction between he and she is often difficult for me).
The article did a good job presenting both sides. Whatever position we take, this is not an easy issue. I use the rubric that our job is not to get lost people to act like Christians. A closer at-hand problem, however, is that kids in our churches may opt for some of these strange pronouns. I am not in a large metro area, but even in a town of 50K, here up north the junior high kids say all kinds of things about how they identify — usually to their school mates, not their pastor. It is a fad, but something worse than a fad.
My niece likes “they/them”, and is dressing in a stereotypically masculine way—while looking longingly at the dance floor at my daughter’s wedding reception. Yes, I considered asking her to dance. I also have the question of whether to honor the request fairly often when I go out for coffee. It is one of those “you know, ma’am, you’re really not fooling anyone” kind of things most of the time. (I’ve mostly interacted with F-M trans who are generally “people of surplus weight”. Generally, their mannerisms are very feminine.)
Discussion
NewIs this more common in other regions?
The author of the above article suggests that most of his unsaved friends use pronoun introductions. I had heard about it, but had not personally experienced it. Yesterday was the first time I had someone introduce themselves with pronouns. I was very confused because I thought she said she used he/her pronouns, but my wife later clarified that she had said she used she/her. I wanted to be polite to her, but was very confused and thankfully I was able to talk to her without using either. Perhaps I need to get a hearing aid so I do not end up offending someone. (I am not trying to be rude about the hearing aid thing, but as a child I was diagnosed with some hearing loss, so the distinction between he and she is often difficult for me).
NewGood Article But Not Sure
The article did a good job presenting both sides. Whatever position we take, this is not an easy issue. I use the rubric that our job is not to get lost people to act like Christians. A closer at-hand problem, however, is that kids in our churches may opt for some of these strange pronouns. I am not in a large metro area, but even in a town of 50K, here up north the junior high kids say all kinds of things about how they identify — usually to their school mates, not their pastor. It is a fad, but something worse than a fad.
"The Midrash Detective"
NewVery real issue
My niece likes “they/them”, and is dressing in a stereotypically masculine way—while looking longingly at the dance floor at my daughter’s wedding reception. Yes, I considered asking her to dance. I also have the question of whether to honor the request fairly often when I go out for coffee. It is one of those “you know, ma’am, you’re really not fooling anyone” kind of things most of the time. (I’ve mostly interacted with F-M trans who are generally “people of surplus weight”. Generally, their mannerisms are very feminine.)
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.
NewSolution - just use his/her - they/them's name
Solution - just use his/her - they/them’s name
Especially works if it is Pat