“The real problem in the article is not, however, simply that we have ‘an aging society with fewer children,’ but this: a 99-year-old woman with living descendants was living alone. This is a problem I and probably you readers have seen increasingly.” - J.C.Blakeney
Discussion
NewPause
He’s too hard on Renn, making negative assumptions about his thought process. But some good points.
To me, the question is, what does Grandma want? The elderly I know personally want to be independent as long as possible. To many, that’s synonymous with living alone. I don’t think that’s good for them. I’m not that far away myself and I hope I remember that it’s not good for me either.
But the upside of AI and robots in this situation is facilitating a longer period of “taking care of myself with the aid of some advanced tools.” That has a lot of appeal.
The elderly I know well also don’t want to “be a burden” to the family. Realistically, that’s not possible. But it’s not unfair the kids were “a burden” (as well as a blessing) when they were little and I’m going to be one (hopefully also a blessing) when I get old enough.
Still, if the technology can help me reduce the burden, that, again, has a lot of appeal.
But the aloneness is really a separate question. You can be with family and friends without being dependent physically on them.
Views expressed are always my own and not my employer's, my church's, my family's, my neighbors', or my pets'. The house plants have authorized me to speak for them, however, and they always agree with me.
NewA bit about capabilities
I'm all for people being close to aging relatives, and for them interacting with aging friends--I minister frequently at a local nursing home, and one thing my wife and I are keen on doing is making sure that we shake hands and have physical contact.
That noted, one thing we've learned as we periodically care for my in-laws is that it matters a LOT whether a family has the physical, financial, and relational capability of providing this care. If the family does not have this--my wife's family does not--then I don't believe it violates 1 Timothy 5:8 to hire some of it done. To draw a picture, it doesn't do my in-laws any good if I spend all my time caring for them, and lose my job or throw out my back in the process. The author is right that we ought to concentrate on relationships, but if relationships are broken (for all of my wife's siblings, they are) and bodies are weak (again, they are), it's no gain to pretend to care for them and further destroy your body, finances, and relationships for the sake of an inheritance.
And as I've said before, DO YOUR SQUATS. Medicare and Medicaid are grossly under funded going forwards, so having a bit of extra strength through your whole body will be golden going forward--whether you're the elder or the person helping them.
Aspiring to be a stick in the mud.